The Spider-Man star is currently starring with Dennis in boundary-breaking Disney film Strange World, which has been praised by critics ahead of its release later this month.
It’s not the first time Jake and Dennis have starred opposite each other, as they played a father and son in 2004 disaster epic The Day After Tomorrow.
Jake was reminded of this project in a new interview with Yahoo Entertainment when the reporter brought it up, and his reaction was instantaneous.
Confused, shocked, delighted, ecstatic – while Dennis simply appeared to laugh at his co-star.
‘You and Dennis obviously played father and son in The Day After Tomorrow a few years back,’ the reporter began, before Jake turned to Dennis and asked: ‘We did?’
‘Oh,’ he said, looking confused. ‘Oh.’
Then: ‘OH!’ as recognition seemed to dawn and he pointed at Dennis, who was smiling and nodding.
‘It’s the first time we’ve been in the same room together,’ Dennis said, as an excited Jake called out: ‘That’s the guy who played – who played my dad!
‘Wow, that’s cool!’ he said.
The interview clip has, unsurprisingly, spread across the internet, being shared thousands of times on TikTok and Twitter.
But fans can’t decide – was Jake serious? Or could the Oscar-nominated actor be acting?
One person on team ‘he-was-being-serious’ argued: ‘To be fair – Jake has done 36 movies since The Day After Tomorrow … and I don’t think they had that many scenes together.’
While another jokingly scolded Jake, reminding him that Dennis’ character had ‘walked uphill in the snow to come save you.’
‘In Jake Gyllenhaal’s defense, they shared 2, maybe 3 short scenes together in the movie,’ another follower wrote, while one claimed: ‘Dennis low key hurt though.’
One follower became suspicious however, and noted: ‘Dennis Quaid responded like this isn’t the first time they’ve had this conversation.’
Another thought Jake was ‘just being very sarcastic,’ with one agreeing it was totally his ‘sense of humor.’
And another wrote in a tone so exasperated it could be heard over text: ‘Y’all realize he’s acting right.’
One viewer who saw the light admitted Jake ‘got’ them, joking: ‘Sarcasm on 9000 because your boy almost got me!’
New project Strange World is being praised for featuring Disney’s first openly gay character, and tells the story of Ethan Clade, the grandson of legendary explorer Jaeger Clade (Dennis) and son of the more reserved explorer-turned-farmer Searcher Clade (Jake).
With Jaeger lost on an expedition 25 years ago, and the valuable crop that Searcher discovered on that trip inexplicably dying off, the family team up to journey into a treacherous land where fantastical creatures await, to try and save their way of living.
Got a story?
If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us firstname.lastname@example.org, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.
MORE : Jake Gyllenhaal hopes to become a dad one day after being an uncle ‘changed’ him
MORE : Conor McGregor to star alongside Jake Gyllenhaal in remake of classic action film Road House